Episode 27

Why Your Facebook Group is Failing: Build a Real Community That Thrives

Are you pouring your heart and soul into your Facebook group but feeling like you're getting nowhere with engagement? Trust me, it's not your content—it's the platform. In today's episode of Your Community Strategist, we're diving into why Facebook groups are failing to deliver the meaningful connections you're hoping for and what you can do about it.

We’ll talk about why Facebook’s algorithm is a silent engagement killer and how distractions are pulling your members away before they even have a chance to engage. But don’t worry—there’s hope! I’ll share alternative platforms designed for real community building, like Circle, that can help you create an engaged, thriving space where members show up, connect, and stay for the long haul.

If you’ve been feeling stuck with your Facebook group, this episode is packed with insights and actionable steps to help you transition to a better community space. Your members deserve a place where real connections flourish—let’s make it happen!

Listen now and don’t forget to subscribe, leave a review, and share this episode with a fellow community builder who's ready to level up their game!

Timestamps:

00:00 The Struggle with Facebook Groups

01:01 Meet Your Host: Rachel Starr

02:38 Why Facebook Groups Are Failing

05:51 Exploring Better Alternatives

06:40 Deep Dive into Circle

15:14 Making the Switch: Steps and Tips

17:11 Success Stories and Final Thoughts

Resources & Links:

Next Episode All Episodes Previous Episode

About the Podcast

Show artwork for Your Community Strategist
Your Community Strategist
Mastering the art of community one strategy at a time.

Listen for free

About your host

Profile picture for Rachel Starr

Rachel Starr

Hi friends! I'm Rachel Starr – founder of coCreator Society and community strategist with 20+ years of helping creators build thriving businesses and communities.

I'm basically Leslie Knope with tech skills, turning complex community challenges into strategic solutions. From my podcast "Your Community Strategist" to building The Co-Op community, I'm all about helping creators connect, collaborate, and grow without the overwhelm.

When I'm not building platforms that actually work for people, you'll find me on the ski slopes, caffeinating heavily, or wrangling two awesome teenagers. I believe the best business happens when great people find each other – which is exactly why coCreator Society exists.

Here's to new adventures, epic collaborations, and really good coffee!